Newbies obscured in ‘Scrubs’ 2.0

Published 4:00 am Thursday, December 3, 2009

Imagine indulging in a passionate goodbye with someone, only to turn the corner and bump into him five minutes later. That sums up the experience of watching the season premiere of the medical comedy “Scrubs,” which, after seemingly wrapping up for good last spring after eight years, makes an inexplicable return as a hybrid reincarnation/sort-of spinoff of its former self.

After Season 8’s touching finale, which tied up every story line, no one seems more nervous for reaction about “Scrubs” 2.0 than the people who make the show. “‘Scrubs’ will be back, but in a new incarnation. … I know many of you will have very strong opinions on this topic,” series star Zach Braff, who plays J.D., wrote on his MySpace page back in May, adding, “Don’t hate it until you see what (executive producer Bill Lawrence) comes up with.”

The first few minutes of Tuesday’s premiere took place at some vague point in the future. Sacred Heart Hospital has been torn down, replaced by a new hospital built on the campus of a medical school, in which implausible — but hopefully hilarious — medical melodramas will surely play out.

Some of the show’s original cast members (John C. McGinley as Dr. Cox, Donald Faison as Turk) have stayed behind as teachers, while others will make guest appearances (including Sarah Chalke as Elliot, now J.D.’s pregnant wife, and Ken Jenkins as Dr. Kelso); and the real action will focus on a group of four new, and of course, much younger, faces. Yet having members of the previous cast remain even temporarily — Braff will only appear in six episodes — weighs down the premiere.

The best part of a new show is the mystery and discovering hidden depths to odd characters, so there’s a bit of a letdown here. While this “Scrubs” is technically “new,” we’re already well-versed with the characters’ quirks; such as knowing Dr. Cox does indeed have a heart, despite telling a class in the first episode: “Turns out you’re not actually medical students at all. You’re all murderers and assassins that have been sent here to try to kill my patients.”

Not enough time is spent on the “Scrubs” 2.0 cast to tell whether they’ll be any fun, though the most promising are Denise (Eliza Coupe) and Drew (Michael Mosley). Both are brilliant yet incapable of emotion, so naturally they start a torrid affair. Lucy (Kerry Bishe), a socially inept student, takes over from J.D. as narrator of the series through her inner monologue.

Conventional wisdom suggests the audience will find comfort in the familiar original characters. In reality, the best plan is to go forward. We’ve said our goodbyes; it’s time to move on.

‘Scrubs’

When: Tuesdays at 9

Where: ABC

Marketplace