Germany’s high court OKs another bailout
Published 5:00 am Thursday, September 8, 2011
LONDON — European economies and investors dodged a bullet Wednesday when Germany’s high court ruled that the nation’s participation in bailing out its debt-ridden neighbors did not violate the constitution.
But the judges warned the German government not to assume it had a blank check for more financial rescues. Instead, any future bailouts need the approval of lawmakers charged with overseeing the budget. The requirement could slow down efforts to address Europe’s spiraling debt crisis, which has regularly outpaced politicians’ ability to respond.
Still, the court’s qualified support for emergency aid to flailing Eurozone countries came as a relief to nervous investors. The region’s major stock exchanges closed higher Wednesday after steep losses in recent days driven by alarm that the debt crisis was spinning out of control.
Had the high court gone against expectation and declared bailouts unlawful, the effect could well have been of a bomb going off in the marketplace, instantly raising the specter of default for Greece, Ireland and Portugal. As Europe’s biggest economy, Germany is on tap for the lion’s share of the emergency loans those three nations have been granted in order to keep paying their bills.
“For the market it could’ve created a lot more uncertainty. It could’ve been a horrible day,” said Azad Zangana, chief European economist with the financial management company Schroders.
But the markets are unlikely to breathe easy for long. Serious concerns persist over the indebtedness of big European countries such as Italy and Spain, and the new demand that German lawmakers vet bailouts adds more bureaucratic cumbersomeness at a time when Europe’s leaders need to move more quickly to react to financial flare-ups.
“In the future they’ll have to start debating these things much, much earlier domestically before taking the process forward. For that to happen, you’ll have to see better leadership,” Zangana said.
Germans on the hook
The court ruling came in response to legal complaints by German academics and others over Germany’s involvement in last year’s rescue package for Greece and in the setup of a fund to help other debt-burdened Eurozone nations. Many Germans are angry at being on the hook for the mistakes and irresponsible decisions of other countries.
But the judges rejected arguments that the Greek bailout undermined the German parliament’s control over tax money.
In Berlin, Chancellor Angela Merkel hailed the decision as a victory for her government and told lawmakers that it was imperative for Germany to defend the European single currency. “The euro is the guarantor of a unified Europe,” she said. “If the euro collapses, Europe collapses.”
Fears for the euro’s health have grown significantly in recent weeks, however, amid reports that Greece is falling far short of its budget-deficit reduction targets and that Italy is backpedaling on its own government austerity efforts.
Late Wednesday, the Italian Senate approved an austerity package that will increase the sales tax on some goods and services, raise income tax for wealthy individuals who earn more than about $422,000 a year and speed up plans to boost the retirement age for women.
The lower house has still to vote on it.
In Athens, European Union officials and inspectors from the International Monetary Fund have warned the Greek government that it may not receive its next installment of bailout loans because of its laggardly implementation of promised reforms.
On Tuesday, Finance Minister Evangelos Venizelos told reporters that “Greece is not the pariah of the European Union” and tried to assure investors that Athens would follow through on labor and structural reforms.